Earth-sized tests of long-range neutrino interactions

Standard

Do neutrinos feel a new long-range force, sourced by ordinary matter, that tells their flavors apart?

Neutrinos come in three flavors (electron, muon, and tau) and change from one flavor to another as they travel. Such a force would be carried by a new, very light particle, the Z′ boson of a new U(1)′ gauge symmetry. The electrons, protons, and neutrons of the Earth would create a potential that acts differently on each flavor and changes how neutrinos oscillate. For the Z′ masses that we study, from 10−15 to 10−9 eV, the force has a range of about 200 m to 30 Earth radii.

In a new paper led by Dyer F. Cardenas (PUCP, Lima, Peru), now an MSc student, who took part through the REPU program, we look for this force with atmospheric neutrinos that cross the Earth on their way to the IceCube DeepCore detector, at the South Pole. Inside the Earth, the potential changes along the path of each neutrino, more so the shorter the range of the force. Earlier analyses of the same data held the potential at its value at the detector. We compute it at every point of each path and use it to analyze eight years of public DeepCore data, with the systematic uncertainties of IceCube’s own analysis.

An atmospheric neutrino crosses the layers of the Earth on its way to IceCube DeepCore; dashed circles around three points of its path have a radius equal to the range of the force.
An atmospheric neutrino crosses the Earth on its way to IceCube DeepCore. Each dashed circle has a radius equal to the range of the force, 1/m′, where m′ is the mass of the Z′. The potential at each point of the path comes mostly from the matter within a few ranges of it, so the potential changes as the neutrino moves.
An atmospheric neutrino crosses the Earth on its way to IceCube DeepCore, with a map of where its potential comes from. The animation ends with the data and our limit.

We set upper limits on the coupling of the Z′ for eight of the 14 symmetries that we study, those whose potential differs between muon and tau neutrinos. At ranges longer than about 1–12 km, depending on the symmetry, our limits are stronger than those from tests of the equivalence principle, by up to almost two orders of magnitude. These tests, with torsion balances and with the MICROSCOPE satellite, look for a force that pulls differently on bodies of different composition. They test how such a force acts on neutrinos only indirectly. Holding the potential at its value at the detector, as earlier analyses did, underestimates it along most of each path, since the mantle and the core are denser than the matter around the detector. Doing so would weaken our limits by about 20% at the longest ranges and by up to a factor of about 3 at the shortest.

Upper limit on the coupling of an L_e − L_μ interaction versus the mediator mass, from this work, compared with an earlier DeepCore limit and with tests of the equivalence principle.
Upper limits on the coupling of the Z′ for one of the symmetries that we study, Le − Lμ, whose charge is the electron-flavor number minus the muon-flavor number. The limits are shown versus the mass of the Z′ (bottom axis) and the range of the force (top axis). Our limit uses the potential along each path. The earlier limit, from the same DeepCore data, holds the potential constant along each path (it ends at the edge of the figure of that paper). It also differs from ours in other choices of the analysis. Tests of the equivalence principle exclude the hatched region.

Along the diameter of the Earth, standard oscillations turn nearly all muon neutrinos with energies near 24 GeV into other flavors. A potential that treats muon and tau neutrinos differently reduces their mixing, so more of them would reach the detector as muon neutrinos. Our limits come from these steeply up-going muon neutrinos. For the other six symmetries, whose potential acts on electron neutrinos alone, the data set no upper limit, since such a potential barely changes how muon neutrinos oscillate.

Detectors under construction or planned, such as the IceCube Upgrade, KM3NeT/ORCA, Hyper-Kamiokande, and DUNE, could tighten these limits. At every range that we study, the potential varies along the path of each neutrino, so analyses of their data should also compute it point by point. Our limits, the numbers behind every figure of the paper, and the code that draws them are public on GitHub.

Read more at:

Earth-sized tests of long-range neutrino interactions
Dyer F. Cardenas, Mauricio Bustamante
2611.14642 hep-ph

Magnus: neutrino oscillation probabilities for any Hamiltonian, in any number of flavors

Standard

Documentation: https://mbustama.github.io/Magnus/

Notebooks: https://mbustama.github.io/Magnus/tutorials.html

Source code: https://github.com/mbustama/Magnus

PyPI: https://pypi.org/project/magnuspy/

Oscillations in matter are usually computed by pretending the matter holds still: chop the path into slabs of constant density, solve each one exactly, multiply. It is a good trick, and for a neutrino crossing the Earth it is nearly the truth. For the Sun, for a supernova, for anything with a front moving through it, the pretending is where the physics is.

Magνs is my new package for that case. It computes oscillation probabilities for an arbitrary number of flavors, under any Hamiltonian, whether or not it depends on time. Rather than stepping the Schrödinger equation forward, it integrates the Hamiltonian across each slab and exponentiates the result — the Magnus expansion. The useful consequence is structural: however hard the expansion is truncated, the truncation stays inside the Lie algebra, so the evolution operator is exactly unitary by construction. Probabilities come out non-negative and summing to one at machine precision, at every accuracy setting, not only the expensive ones.

What it makes easy

  • A density that actually changes — a tabulated solar model, a supernova profile from a simulation, a shock front.
  • An accuracy instead of a slab count — ask for a tolerance and the refinement finds the resolution for you.
  • Any number of flavors — two through five, sterile states (3+1, 3+2) included.
  • The phase-averaged probability, in closed form — the quantity a solar experiment actually measures, returned directly rather than reconstructed by averaging a scan.
  • Neutrinos through the Earth — you give a direction, not a profile.

Install with:

pip install magnuspy

The import package is magnus. Python 3.10 or newer, GPL-3.0-only, and 27 example notebooks that are executed in CI, so the numbers printed in them cannot quietly drift.

A minimal example

A 10 GeV muon neutrino arriving from below, crossing the Earth:

import magnus.oscprob as oscprob
import magnus.globaldefs as gd
import magnus.earth as earth
# A 10 GeV muon neutrino crossing the Earth, arriving from below.
costhz = -0.4
L = earth.distance_traveled_inside_earth(costhz)*gd.UNIT_KM # chord: km -> eV^-1
P = oscprob.osc_prob_3nu_earth(10.0*gd.UNIT_GEV, costhz=costhz, L=L)
print('Pme = %.5f, Pmm = %.5f, Pmt = %.5f'
% (P[gd.NUMU][gd.NUE], P[gd.NUMU][gd.NUMU], P[gd.NUMU][gd.NUTAU]))

which prints

Pme = 0.10273, Pmm = 0.01165, Pmt = 0.88562

The oscillation parameters are never mentioned, because they default to the current global fit (NuFIT 6.1). Neither is the Earth’s density: the wrapper walks the PREM profile for the chord that the zenith angle picks out. What you supply is a direction and an energy.

How it differs from NuOscProbExact

Both packages are mine, and they are not competitors — the honest way to put it is as a boundary rather than a winner. NuOscProbExact solves each constant-density slab in closed form, through SU(2), SU(3) and SU(4) expansions. It is exact up to round-off, there is no slab count to argue about, and it is fast. Where a closed form exists and the accumulated phase is large, use the closed form — including the Earth through PREM at three flavors, where NuOscProbExact is about 20× cheaper per call than Magνs. That is its home ground.

Magνs integrates across each slab instead, which is exactly what lets it follow a density that changes while the neutrino is still inside it. Reach for it when the profile varies continuously, when you would rather ask for an accuracy than guess a resolution, when you need five flavors — the SU(N) closed forms stop at SU(4) — or when the Hamiltonian is something nobody has diagonalized.

Two measurements make the difference concrete. On a smooth profile, multiplying constant-density slabs together bottoms out near 2.5 × 10⁻¹¹ and then gets worse: past roughly 16 000 slabs, round-off from composing that many matrix products outgrows anything a finer grid buys. Magνs keeps going to 2.9 × 10⁻¹³. And for the Sun, it returns 40 phase-averaged energies in about 0.7 s, where nuSQuIDS needs on the order of ten minutes merely to reach the solver tolerance at which its output is a probability at all.

The two packages deliberately share conventions, units and parameter defaults, so a calculation can be moved from one to the other and used as a cross-check on itself. I do this often.

Some physics it’s meant for

Each of these has a worked notebook in the tutorial gallery, and there is a systematic comparison against other codes in the documentation.

  • Long-baseline beams and atmospheric neutrinos through the Earth.
  • Solar neutrinos on a real tabulated model, including the averaged observable.
  • Supernova neutrinos across a shock front — where the width of the front is what decides which method the problem belongs to.
  • Sterile states (3+1 and 3+2), non-standard interactions, Lorentz-invariance violation.
  • A Hamiltonian of your own — the escape hatch, and the reason the rest of the list is not exhaustive.

NuOscProbExact 1.11.0: exact neutrino oscillation probabilities for two, three, and now four flavors — on PyPI!

Standard

Documentation: https://mbustama.github.io/NuOscProbExact/

Notebooks: https://github.com/mbustama/NuOscProbExact/tree/main/notebooks

Source code: https://github.com/mbustama/NuOscProbExact

PyPI: https://pypi.org/project/nuoscprobexact/

Neutrino oscillation probabilities look like a solved problem until the Hamiltonian stops being the textbook one. There is a closed form in vacuum, and another in two-flavor constant-density matter, and after that it runs out. Add a realistic density profile, a non-standard interaction, a Lorentz-violating operator or a fourth state, and the usual options are to expand in a parameter that may not be small, to diagonalise the Hamiltonian numerically at every point of a grid, or to integrate the Schrödinger equation and hope the step was short enough.

NuOscProbExact does none of these. The Hamiltonian and the time-evolution operator are expanded in the basis of SU(2), SU(3) or SU(4) matrices, and exponentiated analytically using the closure of the algebra. What comes out is a closed form for the probabilities in terms of two or three invariants of the Hamiltonian: no eigenvectors, no numerical diagonalisation, no integration, and no approximation beyond floating-point round-off. Any Hermitian 2×2, 3×3 or 4×4 matrix will do, whatever physics put it there. The method is Ohlsson and Snellman’s, revisited in the 2019 paper; the extension to SU(4) is new since then.

Four flavors is where it stops, for a reason external to neutrino physics: at five, the eigenvalues stop being expressible in radicals — Abel–Ruffini — and the closed form ends with them. Four is exactly what 3+1 needs.

If your reference point is a numerical evolution code, the output is the same object — probabilities, or the evolution operator itself — but with no step size to converge and no dependency beyond numpy. I wrote the first version because adding a model should mean writing down a matrix, not writing a solver. Seven years on it does rather more than it did, and version 1.11.0 now installs with pip.

What it makes easy

  • Any model, without a new code path. Vacuum, matter, non-standard interactions, Lorentz-invariance violation, sterile states: none of these is a special case in the code. Each is a different matrix handed to the same routine.
  • A whole scan in one call. A curve against energy or baseline, or a full oscillogram over both, with no Python loop.
  • Neutrinos through the Earth. Along a zenith angle, or between two of fifteen named sites — CERN–Gran Sasso, Fermilab–Homestake, Tokai–Kamioka and others — with the density profile taken from PREM. Or through any hand-built sequence of slabs of arbitrary width and density, each solved exactly and the operators multiplied.
  • 3+1 sterile scenarios at four flavors, as closed four-state systems rather than as leakage out of the three-flavor block.
  • The evolution operator itself, not only probabilities, for composing across segments or propagating a density matrix.

Install with:

pip install nuoscprobexact

and, for the optional compiled backend:

pip install "nuoscprobexact[fast]"

MIT licence. Python 3.9 or newer, tested on 3.9 through 3.13, and numpy is the only required dependency: no compiler, nothing to build.

Main features

Accuracy

  • Cross-checked against independently written code. The probabilities agree with nuSQuIDS to round-off once conventions are matched, and the matter spectrum agrees with the Zaglauer–Schwarzer closed form.
  • A regression suite of 596 tests, at 100% coverage.

Speed

  • Arrays instead of loops. Stacks of Hamiltonians, arrays of baselines, or both broadcast together: roughly 20x to 90x faster than the equivalent Python loop, with no extra dependency.
  • An optional compiled backend. With numba installed, the batched paths run as compiled kernels — answers identical to round-off, used only where it has been measured to win.

What you need to provide

You provide a Hermitian matrix and a baseline, built by hand or with one of the bundled builders for the standard cases. The package returns the exact evolution operator and the probabilities that follow from it, and stops there: no fluxes, no cross sections, no detector response, no fitting. One assumption is worth stating plainly: the Hamiltonian is taken to be time-independent over each segment. A smoothly varying profile can be slabbed, but the step size is then set by the oscillation rather than by the density, and there the documentation points at a Magnus-type method instead.

A minimal example

import numpy as np
import oscprob3nu
import hamiltonians3nu
from globaldefs import *
# The vacuum Hamiltonian, without the 1/E factor, so an energy scan
# computes it once
h_vac = hamiltonians3nu.hamiltonian_3nu_vacuum_energy_independent(
S12_NO_BF, S23_NO_BF, S13_NO_BF, DCP_NO_BF, D21_NO_BF, D31_NO_BF)
# One probability, at 1 GeV over 1300 km
Pee, Pem, Pet, Pme, Pmm, Pmt, Pte, Ptm, Ptt = oscprob3nu.probabilities_3nu(
np.asarray(h_vac)/1.e9, 1300.0*CONV_KM_TO_INV_EV)
print('Pee = %.5f, Pem = %.5f, Pet = %.5f' % (Pee, Pem, Pet))

prints

Pee = 0.92768, Pem = 0.01432, Pet = 0.05800


(The quickstart goes through this more slowly; the recipes page has short, complete snippets for most of what the package can compute, each with real output.)

What is new since 1.0.0

The original announcement, in May 2019, covered the method paper and the code on GitHub. The method has not changed since; almost everything around it has. Whole-array scans arrived in 1.2.0, the optional numba backend in 1.6.0, the Earth and arbitrary layered matter in 1.8.0, and four flavors — oscprob4nu, hamiltonians4nu, the SU(4) expansion — in 1.9.0. In 1.11.0, a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian raises instead of quietly returning probabilities that still sum to one. Along the way, a documentation site and eighteen worked notebooks.

One thing to flag for anyone still running 1.0.0: two fixes in 1.1.0 changed numbers, both at two flavors. probabilities_2nu was missing the h2 contribution to P(νe → νμ), which is invisible whenever the off-diagonal entry is real — so vacuum and constant-density matter were unaffected, but a CP-violating two-flavor Hamiltonian was not — and the two-flavor vacuum Hamiltonian used the opposite sign convention, invisible in vacuum and consequential once a matter potential is added. Three-flavor results from 1.0.0 are unaffected; the changelog has the details.

Some physics it’s meant for

Long-baseline accelerator experiments. DUNE-like baselines through the crust, with matter effects and the CP phase, and the bi-probability ellipses above, which show how matter pushes neutrinos and antineutrinos off the CP-symmetric diagonal. Notebook 05.

Atmospheric neutrinos through the Earth. Zenith-angle scans with the density taken from PREM rather than from a single average value, which is where the mass ordering and the θ23 octant separate. Notebooks 07 and 12.

Sterile neutrinos, 3+1. Short-baseline appearance and disappearance, and the sterile matter resonance through the Earth, with the four states treated as a closed, unitary system rather than as leakage out of the three-flavor block. Notebook 16.

Non-standard interactions and Lorentz-invariance violation. Both enter as extra Hermitian terms added to the vacuum Hamiltonian, so a new operator means a new matrix, not a new solver. Notebook 03.

Unusual matter profiles. Castle-wall and other hand-built profiles, where the arrangement of the matter changes the answer even when the mean density does not — a parametric-resonance effect no constant-density approximation can show. Notebook 08.