Constraining tau–sterile neutrino mixing with high-energy astrophysical neutrinos

Standard

Does a fourth neutrino, one that does not feel the weak interaction, mix with the three known ones?

Anomalies in short-baseline experiments have pointed to such a sterile neutrino, through its mixing with electron and muon neutrinos, although global fits find them in tension with other data. Its mixing with tau neutrinos, quantified by |Uτ4|², is the least tested. There are no intense beams of tau neutrinos, so terrestrial experiments probe this mixing only indirectly, through its effect on muon neutrinos, and each one only over a limited range of sterile-neutrino masses.

In a new paper with Qinrui Liu (Simon Fraser University), we show that high-energy astrophysical neutrinos test this mixing differently. These neutrinos, with TeV–PeV energies, are produced in cosmic accelerators, mainly in the decays of charged pions. Their sources make almost no tau neutrinos. Yet, over the cosmological distances that separate the sources from Earth, oscillations turn part of the electron and muon neutrinos into tau neutrinos. About one third of the neutrinos that reach Earth are expected to be tau neutrinos.

If tau neutrinos mix with a sterile neutrino, a fraction |Uτ4|² of these tau neutrinos goes missing, turned into sterile neutrinos that neutrino telescopes cannot see. The tau-neutrino fraction that the telescopes measure drops, while the ratio of electron to muon neutrinos stays as it is. This deficit is the same whatever the mass of the sterile neutrino. Of the three mixings of the sterile neutrino with the known ones, only this one leaves a mark that flavor measurements can detect even though we do not know what the sources emit.

Measuring the deficit is hard. In neutrino telescopes, tau and electron neutrinos leave similar signals, which makes present flavor measurements imprecise. Earlier work mapped the flavor composition that sterile mixing could produce at Earth. We do the reverse: we fit the mixing to flavor measurements, leaving the flavor composition at the sources free.

Using the flavor composition measured by IceCube with its latest sample of Medium-Energy Starting Events (MESE), we find |Uτ4|² < 0.88 at 90% C.L. This disfavors only mixing large enough to remove most of the tau neutrinos. Combining IceCube with present and planned neutrino telescopes, including IceCube-Gen2 and HUNT, could lower this limit to 0.24–0.29 by 2040 and to 0.12–0.14 by 2050, depending on how the neutrinos are made at the sources.

Limits on the mixing of tau neutrinos with a sterile neutrino, from high-energy astrophysical neutrinos today (pink) and projected for 2040 and 2050, compared with terrestrial limits (gray). The vertical axis, Δm²41, is the difference between the squared mass of the fourth neutrino and that of the first known one.

Our limits hold at every value of the sterile-neutrino mass, unlike most terrestrial ones, which each cover only a limited range. By 2050, they would be stronger than those of Super-K and MINOS and similar to that of a global fit of terrestrial data. They would remain weaker than the strongest terrestrial limits, from atmospheric neutrinos at the eV scale, from NOνA, and, in the future, from DUNE. Still, they would complement them: they hold at small mass splittings, where most terrestrial experiments set no limit, and they rest on different systematic uncertainties.

The main goal of next-generation neutrino telescopes is to find and understand the sources of high-energy astrophysical neutrinos. Their flavor measurements would also test, at no extra cost, whether a sterile neutrino mixes with tau neutrinos.

Read more at:

Constraining tau–sterile neutrino mixing with high-energy astrophysical neutrinos
Mauricio Bustamante, Qinrui Liu
2611.05170 hep-ph

The renormalization-group running of neutrino mixing is undetectable

Standard

Do neutrinos mix differently depending on how they are made or detected?

Today, solar, reactor, accelerator, and atmospheric neutrino experiments measure neutrino mixing at energies from MeV to TeV. Global fits combine all of them into a single set of mixing angles and a CP phase. That this works rests on an assumption so basic that it is rarely stated: every experiment sees the same mixing.

In quantum field theory, the parameters of a theory, like the strength of a force or the mixing angles, depend on the energy scale at which we choose to describe them. This “renormalization-group running” is a standard and powerful tool. It connects theories defined at very high energies, like grand unified theories, to the values we measure in the lab.

In recent years, a growing number of papers, including some of our own, went a step further. They assumed that the running is directly observable. In this view, a neutrino made or detected in a collision carries the mixing evaluated at the momentum transfer of that collision, roughly, at how hard the collision is. This would lead to striking signals:

  • neutrinos changing flavor right at their source;
  • different values of the CP phase in different experiments;
  • unusual flavor ratios of the high-energy astrophysical neutrinos seen by IceCube.

In a new paper with Gabriela Barenboim (IFIC, University of Valencia) and Qinrui Liu (Simon Fraser University), we show that this premise is incorrect. The mixing is a property of the neutrino itself. It is fixed by quantum corrections to the neutrino as it travels freely from source to detector.

For the mixing to depend on the momentum transfer, the momentum transfer would have to enter those corrections. It does not: in the collisions that create and detect the neutrino, the momentum is exchanged through a W boson, not through the traveling neutrino. One can still choose to evaluate the mixing at the momentum transfer, as earlier works did. But then the corrections to the traveling neutrino, which those works left out, undo the running. Apart from tiny corrections at the collision points, every experiment, at any energy, measures the same mixing.

Neutrinos are made and detected in collisions with different momentum transfers (top). Earlier works assumed that the mixing changes with it (red). In fact, the traveling neutrino fixes the mixing, and it is the same in every experiment (blue).

The running itself is real, and it remains useful for testing theories at high energies. What cannot be seen is a dependence of the mixing on the momentum transfer of the experiment. Even setting the theory aside, old data rule this out. The NuTeV and NOMAD experiments looked for neutrinos changing flavor close to their source. They limit any change in the mixing angles between production in pion decay and detection at a few GeV to below 0.7°–2.4°.

This tells us where not to look. If future measurements deviate from expectations, for example of the flavor composition of high-energy astrophysical neutrinos, the cause will be genuinely new physics, not the running of the mixing.

Read more at:

The renormalization-group running of neutrino mixing is undetectable
Gabriela Barenboim, Mauricio Bustamante, Qinrui Liu
2610.28744 hep-ph

Astrophysical bounds on the high-energy evolution of neutrino mixing

Standard

Today, the values of the neutrino mixing angles and mass differences that govern flavor transitions are known to quite high precision. However, we know them exclusively from sub-TeV terrestrial experiments. Because these experiments operate at low transferred momenta (typically, Q ~ few GeV), a fundamental question remains: are the mixing parameters universal constants, or do they evolve at high energies?

Quantum field theory dictates that these parameters should “run” with Q via renormalization group (RG) equations. While this running is negligible in the Standard Model, well-motivated new-physics frameworks, like the Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT), can accelerate this evolution. Detecting the high-energy running of neutrino mixing parameters would be a smoking-gun signature of new physics.

To access the high-Q regime, we turn to high-energy astrophysical neutrinos, with energies in the TeV–PeV and EeV ranges. They interact in neutrino telescopes via deep inelastic scattering and probe average momentum transfers of Q ~ 20-40 GeV, offering an unprecedented window into this high-Q evolution.

In a new paper with Qinrui Liu and Gabriela Barenboim, we evaluate the power of high-energy astrophysical neutrinos to test the evolution of neutrino mixing. We use the neutrino flavor composition at Earth, i.e., the relative proportions of electron, muon, and tau neutrinos in the diffuse flux. We execute a two-pronged analysis: first, extracting generic high-Q mixing parameters to remain model-agnostic, and second, constraining RG-inducing dimension-6 SMEFT coefficients.

We extract present bounds from the 11.4-year IceCube Medium Energy Starting Events (MESE) sample, published in 2025. Because the uncertainties in current flavor measurements are large, present data cannot yet meaningfully constrain the high-Q mixing parameters or SMEFT operators.

However, the future is promising. For our projections, we simulate the combined detection capabilities of existing (IceCube, Baikal-GVD, KM3NeT) and upcoming (P-ONE, IceCube-Gen2, NEON, TRIDENT, HUNT) optical-Cherenkov neutrino telescopes by the years 2040 and 2050, using both High-Energy Starting Events (HESE) and through-going muons. Crucially, we profile over the unknown astrophysical source flavor composition to ensure our bounds are robust and realistic.

Our results show that by 2040–2050, this global network will achieve the precision necessary to place unprecedented bounds on high-Q mixing (yielding particularly strong constraints in the 23 and 13 sectors). Furthermore, if the astrophysical neutrinos are produced via muon-damped pion decay, these telescopes will be capable of placing limits on individual SMEFT coefficients at a new-physics scale of 1 TeV, easily translatable to other energy scales.

We also forecasted the sensitivity of ultra-high-energy (UHE) radio arrays, such as the planned IceCube-Gen2 radio array. Counterintuitively, we found that despite UHE neutrinos possessing much higher energies, they yield drastically weaker constraints than their TeV–PeV counterparts. This is driven both by the logarithmic scaling of the RG evolution and by the vast experimental uncertainties inherent to radio-based flavor tagging.

Read more at:

Astrophysical bounds on the high-energy evolution of neutrino mixing
Mauricio Bustamante, Qinrui Liu, Gabriela Barenboim
2604.14409 hep-ph

Measuring neutrino mixing above 1 TeV with astrophysical neutrinos

Standard

Today, the values of the neutrino mixing angles that govern flavor transitions are known to percent precision (the Dirac CP-violation phase is known much more poorly). However, these values are inferred exclusively from sub-TeV neutrino experiments. No measurement of the mixing parameters exists at the TeV scale and above. There, new-physics effects whose intensity grows with neutrino energy could modify the effective neutrino mixing. High-energy astrophysical neutrinos, with TeV-PeV energies, are primed for such measurements.

In a new paper with Qinrui Liu and Gabriela Barenboim, we have assessed in detail the power in these neutrinos to test mixing above 1 TeV, today and in the future. Concretely, we have extracted values of the four neutrino mixing angles (𝛉12, 𝛉23, 𝛉13) and the CP-violation phase (δCP) from the flavor composition of high-energy astrophysical neutrinos, i.e., the proportion of electron, muon, and tau neutrinos in their diffuse flux.

We extract present bounds on the mixing parameters from the 11.4-year IceCube Medium Energy Starting Events (MESE) sample, published in 2025. We find that the uncertainty in the measurement is too large to claim meaningful sensitivity to the mixing parameter.

For our projections, we use multi-neutrino-telescope combinations using projected detection rates at existing (IceCube, Baikal-GVD, KM3NeT) and future (P-ONE, IceCube-Gen2, NEON, TRIDENT, HUNT) neutrino telescopes. For these, we combine High Energy Starting Events (HESE) and through-going muons. Our projections show clear sensitivity to 𝛉23 and 𝛉13 (and, if neutrino production occurs via muon-damped pion decay, to δCP). This establishes benchmarks for the minimum size that new-physics modifications to the mixing parameters must have in order to be detectable.

Read more at:

Measuring neutrino mixing above 1 TeV with astrophysical neutrinos
Mauricio Bustamante, Qinrui Liu, Gabriela Barenboim
2602.14308 hep-ph

A plethora of long-range neutrino interactions probed by DUNE and T2HK

Standard

If there are new neutrino interactions with matter, and if they affect neutrinos of different flavor differently, then they could impact neutrino oscillations. Long-baseline neutrino experiments are well-suited to look for them, thanks to their use of intense, well-characterized neutrino beams.

If the new interactions have a long range—i.e., if they are mediated by a new, ultra-light mediator—then neutrinos on Earth may experience a matter potential sourced by the vast amount of faraway matter elsewhere inside the Earth, Moon, Sun, Milky Way, and in the cosmological matter distribution, as pointed out in 1808.02042 [Universe’s Worth of Electrons to Probe Long-Range Interactions of High-Energy Astrophysical Neutrinos, by MB & Sanjib Agarwalla, PRL 2019]. This boosts the chances of discovering the new interaction even if it is supremely feeble.

In a recent paper (2305.05184 [Flavor-dependent long-range neutrino interactions in DUNE & T2HK: alone they constrain, together they discover, by Masoom Singh, MB, and Sanjib Agarwalla, JHEP 2023]), we explored the prospects of constraining or discovering these new, long-range neutrino interactions in the upcoming long-baseline experiments DUNE and T2HK. We found promising prospects. However, we explored only three different possible forms of the interaction, introduced by gauging three of the accidental global lepton-number U(1) symmetries of the Standard Model.

In a new paper (2404.02775), led by PhD students Masoom Singh and Pragyanprasu Swain, we now extend this to many other symmetries—a plethora of them!—that introduce new neutrino interactions with electrons, neutrons, and protons. Each symmetry affects oscillations differently.

Our new results cement and extend our original findings: DUNE and T2HK should be able to probe the existence of new interactions—and possibly discover and distinguish between alternatives—regardless of which symmetry is responsible for inducing them. The reach of DUNE and T2HK to probe new neutrino interactions is not only deep, but also broad!

Read more at

A plethora of long-range neutrino interactions probed by DUNE and T2HK
Sanjib Kumar Agarwalla, Mauricio Bustamante, Masoom Singh, Pragyanprasu Swain
2404.02775 hep-ph

Download the digitized data from out plots from this GitHub repository.